What’s a dad to do? Part 1

Every TV and radio show I’ve appeared on since my book’s release asks about the lessons that came out of writing this book. And why not? Parenting is a challenge even under the best of circumstances. And most of us don’t get the best of circumstances.

I deliberately set out to learn about being a father to daughters by talking with daughters. I wanted to hear their stories from the heart, and learn the big lessons for dads as I think people learn best—through storytelling and emotion.

I hope you can read the book and take in the full emotional weight that comes through in the stories. After hundreds hours of conversation, transcribed over 1,500 pages, here what I learned from women who spanned seven decades and about 15 countries.

Remember this: Everything communicates. What we say matters, and what we do matters more. That’s one of the lessons I preach as a marketing strategist and consultant. While more and more dads are coming to understand that when it comes to their businesses lives, many seem to forget it when we get home.

Everything we do communicates something, usually subtly. If we’re disinterested in our daughters, they learn reluctance about their desirability. If we’re distant, they learn that relationships with men are distant. If we’re by her side as she grows up, she learns she’s worthy. If we work hard, if we’re spiritual, if we’re loving, she absorbs that too.

Our actions and lives lay down belief systems that act like software code in our daughters’ minds. We’re shaping our family cultures through how we behave, and our daughters are internalizing those cultures unconsciously as they grow up.

As dads we need to watch what we do. We can all think about it in the morning when we get up and think about it at night when we can reflect on what we did—or didn’t do. Giving our daughters the long straw in a dad isn’t about being perfect. It’s about continually trying to get better.

Daughters—what did your dad communicate to you through what he did with his life?

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

To Dads Everywhere, From Your Daughter

I’m asked all the time if I can distill what I learned over the year that I spent with 50 women sharing their life stories, and how their fathers shaped them. I’ve put those lessons into the following imaginary letter. It’s from every newborn daughter to her father. Feel free to share it.

Dear Dad,

After nine months in the dark, I have just spent 21 hours fighting my way out of that warm, cramped space. I was so happy to see you that I burst out crying.

I already know your voice. And I already feel an attachment to you. Please, don’t ever leave me. Hold me, hug me, and love me every day. Let me sleep on your chest and feel the rhythm of your life feed mine.

I need to be with you. I want you to want me with you. Tell me you love me. Show me you love me. Take me places and do things with me, just me. Anything you want to do is fine. We can go to the race track or parades or baseball games. We can go to breakfast or movies together. We can play catch outside. Take me with you in your garbage truck or to your office.

Take me camping, even if it’s just in our back yard. I need someone to treasure me and fill my heart. If you don’t do it, I may spend the rest of my life looking for someone who will.

Swing me high in the air above your head at the beach. Give me piggyback rides. Chase me and catch me and tickle me. Swim like a shark under water and capture me, then throw me into the air. Let me crawl into bed between you and Mom and then hug me some more. Let me see you smile.

Read to me. Tell me stories. You can make them up, any kind of stories. Tell me about when you were a little boy. Tuck me into bed at night. Let me talk to you, and listen to me, really listen. Try to hear what’s in my heart, because I won’t always know for sure.

Teach me how to be strong and fierce and how to fight for myself. Lay down the law and hold me to it, even when I whine. Show me how to work hard. Teach me about money and power and how to navigate in the world.

Love Mom forever. Show me what I should look for in a life partner by the example you set. Show me I deserve someone who will cherish me, have fun with me, listen to me, bring me flowers for no reason at all. Be the sort of husband that you’d want me to have.

Take me to church, to temple, to God. Help me find the Big Spirit and reverence inside myself, other people, and everything else.

Hold my hand and hug me, even as I get older. Tell me I am beautiful. Let me hear what it feels like when it comes from someone who loves me.

Tell me about yourself. Open your heart to me. Let me know who you really are. Help me come to know you as a man, not just as Planet Dad circling around me as I spin at the center of my own chaotic universe.

Hold me to the high standard of the woman I’ll be grateful to become. Whoever I meet and date, hold them to a high standard, too. Be firm. I don’t need a friend. I need a Father.

Accept and love me for who I am. I may not be the daughter you fantasized about. There may be an artist inside of me, not a doctor. There may be an engineer inside me, not a writer. I may have women lovers, not men. I may choose another religion or none at all. I will find my own political beliefs. Help me find myself. Encourage me. Love me unconditionally, even as I’m different. Just like you were.

Please, Daddy, find yourself. Don’t live a miserable life. Don’t do it for me. Don’t do it for anyone. Let me see love in your heart and light in your soul.

Let me go when my time has come. But the best place you can be is around the corner—out of sight, yet close enough that if I ever need you, you will be there.

Take care of yourself, too. I want my children to know you. I want them to know why I’m crying so hard when I bury you, just like I cried when I came into this world.

Love,

Your Daughter

© Kevin Renner, In Search of Fatherhood: A Mother Lode of Wisdom From the World of Daughterhood, Inkwater Press, 2011

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Inseminator: On ArnoldGate and Daughterhood

A radio station in Milwaukee, Wisconsin asked me for my thoughts on Arnold Schwarzenegger and his daughters.

First, the whole thing is tragic. The media circus only makes it worse. I can’t imagine being a young woman in her late teens or early twenties and going through this. Can you?

A few things stood out for me though as I talked with John Mercure of WTMJ.

How will the fact that Arnold Schwarzenegger fathered a child with his mistress shape his daughters’ views about men?

That’s hard to say, but it certainly won’t bolster their views. Dads are larger than life for daughters when they’re young. Arnold and Maria’s daughters aren’t kids any more, but Arnold was larger than life. Mr. Olympia. Mega-movie star. Governor. He was an icon worldwide, and hopefully a hero to his daughters as they were growing up. That fantasy is over now.

His daughters didn’t just lose the only family they’d known. They’re undoubtedly going through feelings of betrayal, on  top of the disappointment, anger and hurt. Will they have long-term trust issues with men? I don’t know. Had he blown up his marriage ten years ago, the emotional damage would have been greater. But even though his daughters are young women now, I can’t help but feel for them. This has to really, really hurt. And the “collateral damage” to his wife, their sons, and the son of his former house staffer is hard to imagine. 

How does the way a father treats his wife affect his daughters?

It paints a mosaic for what daughters come to know as the normal marriage. Fathers, through how they husband, create what daughters have an appreciation for in partners.

Music might be a good metaphor. Say you grow up listening to classical music & developing an appreciation for it. Then say you move in with a partner who grew up with nothing but punk rock. Now magnify that by 1,000 and that’s how much impact our family dynamics have on us.

As the stories in my book show, patterns tend to repeat themselves, whether loving relationships or abusive relationships.

Will it forever influence their relationship with their dad?

Yes; it either confirms rumors the daughters have heard and suspicions they may have held. Or it rocks their foundation like a mega-quake if it’s completely news. But their father is forever changed in their eyes. Forever. 

Can their relationship with their dad be repaired, and how?

Yes, but it will be difficult. Partly it depends on the quality of relationship they’ve had to date, and whether this is for his daughters “the last straw” or an exception to otherwise devoted fathering.

The onus obviously is on Arnold, and he has to begin by acknowledging his transgressions and the pain they have caused. He has some very heavy lifting to do, unlike any he’s ever done before.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | 1 Comment

The Beginnings of This Journey

Lying in a hospital bed near the end of his ninety years, my German grandfather told his youngest son, “I’ve had a hard life.”

“Yes,” my father replied, “you have.”

My grandfather lost his corner drug store and all of his money during The Great Depression. He moved from South Dakota to a rural Oregon community with his wife and eleven children, and began farming. During World War II, he moved his family to Portland and worked in the shipyards. After retiring, he would walk several miles downtown to pay his utility bills so he could save the cost of postage stamps.

My father has lived a hard life, too. He worked two jobs to put himself through college, sleeping four hours a night. When he and my mother were in their early twenties, they had no money and three children in diapers. My father watched his parents die. He watched his first and only wife, my mother, die. He watched ten siblings die.

As I’ve gotten to know my father better as an adult, it’s become clear that he has mixed feelings about his father. He admires his refusal to succumb to adversity; when his father lost everything, he could have walked away from his family and the overwhelming responsibility. He raised and supported eleven children as best he could. But like many of his generation, and like many fathers in this book, he was harsh, distant, and often critical. And his children resented him for that. Many left home as early as they could.

I am my parents’ first son, and the second of three children. I certainly didn’t grow up deprived, but my life hasn’t been easy, either. Starting the summer that I was ten, I got up at five o’clock in the morning to catch a bus taking kids to work in the berry fields. I made between two and three dollars a day. As a teenager, I slogged through jobs in agriculture, construction, and restaurants. A few years later I put myself through college and then through graduate school five years after that.

My greatest challenges, though, have come during the past fifteen years, as a father raising two rather spirited daughters. I have loved it and struggled with it. Like fathers everywhere, I have no experience whatsoever as a daughter, no idea what it means to be a girl in a relationship with her dad. Two years ago that realization struck me like a hammer in the head.

I woke up one day—and I mean really woke up—with some startling questions running through my mind: “What do you have left to teach your daughters? What’s it like to be a daughter, anyway? To be your daughter? What will your daughters long for as women that they didn’t get from you? What do you have left to learn as a father?” Past the halfway point of my life, I felt like I was stumbling around in the dark while my daughters had blown through childhood into adolescence.

They were nine and thirteen at the time. How did that happen? I traveled a fair amount for my job, but even when I was home, I realized, I wasn’t really there. I was semi-conscious, living in my little cocoon of work and stress. At 52, I still felt like a beta version of fatherware. But there I was, thirteen years into fatherhood. It was too late for a recall on DadWare 1.0.

I woke up with these questions and self-doubts swirling through my head on a remarkable winter day shortly after Christmas. I live in Portland, Oregon, and the entire city was buried under two feet of snow, more than had ever fallen at once in my lifetime. Two inches of snow is a big deal here. Schools were closed for the holiday break, and my office was closed for days.

My world went quiet. For the first time in years, my agitated mind went idle. And I do mean agitated. I dreamed once that I checked into a doctor’s office, and when the receptionist asked me to sign in I wrote my name as “To Do.” So when the weather kept me from going to work, from going anywhere for that matter, it really was a profound change for my mind to be still. This is when the questions began coming to me, about how fathers shape daughters, for better or worse, through their presence or absence in their daughters’ lives.

I wanted to better understand what daughters take in from their fathers and how that happens. I wondered about myself: How much had been passed down to me through what my father internalized from his harsh, critical, and distant father? I was struck by how I’d never given thought to these questions.

I also felt that time was so short. My girls had grown up so quickly. Maybe another dad would have meditated on it or something. Not me. I decided to do something. That’s who I am: To Do.

Just like my questions had hit me head-on, I wanted my answers to do the same. One of my martial arts teachers used to say, “If you want to slay the dragon, you have to go into the dragon’s den.” So with a sense of urgency, and fears of all sorts, I decided to find my dragon’s den and venture inside. I wanted to understand fatherhood and daughterhood from a place I had never been and could never directly experience myself: The heart and soul of a woman, one grown-up daughter after another.

I decided to meet women and ask them to identify what they had absorbed from their fathers, and what they didn’t get that they yearned for. I wanted to find out about this special relationship, and how it set their lives on the trajectories that they’d traveled, so that I could do a better job as the first man in my daughters’ lives.

I’m not a psychotherapist. Nor do I consider myself a writer. I’m a dad, and a businessman. This was something I was simply compelled to do. So I began my journey in search of fatherhood.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | 1 Comment

So, who are you?

“So, who are you?”

This was the first question from the big-name L.A. agent sitting across the table as I pitched my book idea. It was August of 2009.

It wasn’t so much the question as how she asked it. Like, “So, who the hell are you? I’m busy. And important.”

“Excuse me?” I replied.

“Who are you? What have you done? What have you written?”

I can’t say her social graces impressed me. I mean, I got it. She’s trying to cut to the chase and qualify me. “But really,” I thought to myself, “this is her warm up line?”

“I’m not anybody. I’m not an author or celebrity or big name anybody. I’m Dad. Like a billion or two other dads around the world, I get up in the morning, go to work, come home spent and do the best I can at something I know nothing about—raising daughters.

“Like fathers all over, I got trained and licensed to drive. I got older, and trained to be a manager. But I never got trained how to raise a daughter, and I don’t know the first thing about what it means to be a daughter in relationship to her dad.

“So I’m writing a book for dads, and also for the two billion adult daughters around the world who had fathers who loved them, ignored them, or even betrayed their trust and violated them. And that’s what makes this an important book.”

That was my fantasy response anyway. But when you’re writing your first book, you’re in the sucking up business. You suck up to agents. They suck up to acquisition editors. And those editors and their employers, the publishers, suck up to the media for book hype, and to retailers. And they suck up to the public—you and me. So here I was in the first cycle of this big sucking machine that I wanted to wash, rinse and spin my book.

So instead of blurting out my fantasy, I turned off the adolescent rampage running through my mind, and told this agent the truth: I’m a dad, who wanted to do a better job of raising his adolescent daughters before our time together ran out. But I didn’t really know what that “better job” looked like. What exactly, I wondered, do great dad actually do? So I went out and talked to experts—daughters—from around the world.

The women were young and old; rich and poor; well-known and anonymous; lesbian, straight, and transgender. I spoke with professional athletes and former drug addicts. I met women with lives of abundance and others who had been homeless, suicidal, or with so few options that they sold their bodies to men for a living.

We talked for hours. Their intensely personal and emotional stories came up and out like volcanoes exploding and blowing out lava that every time found its own path down its own mountain.

“I’ll tell you what will sell this book,” the big name agent continued. “You go get interviews with Lindsay Lohan or Britney Spears. Now that will sell.”

So ended my pitch.

I couldn’t have cared less about Lindsay or Britney or Paris. At 52, I had just lost my job. I spent the next 18 months starting my own business, writing this book, and learning how to be a better dad. In many ways, it was the hardest year-and-a-half of my life, and in some ways the best.

I set out on my journey of awakening and had no idea how profoundly it would change me. I wanted to understand how fathers shape their daughters. In the process, the 50 daughters I met recreated me as a father. This book—and the lessons for fathers and daughters everywhere—is built upon their stories. And mine.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments